AIYING · PO Thinking Lab
Stuck on an Engineering Problem? Ask AI for One Hint
By Ravindra Dastikop with ChatGPT
An engineering student calculates a salt flow of 2 kg/h and writes down 2%. The arithmetic is right. The mistake is in what the number represents. One well-placed question can help the student spot it and complete the calculation.
Try the PO provocation
PO: The AI tutor is allowed to ask only one question.
What would you ask if you had only one chance to help a student get unstuck? You would look at their working, find the first line that needs attention, and ask a question that helps them decide what to do next.
You can try this with Gemini or another AI assistant. Give it the full problem, your own working, and the units. Then ask for one guiding question and attempt the next step yourself.
Work through a material balance example
One stream brings in 10 kg/h of a 20% salt solution by mass. A second stream brings in 10 kg/h of pure water. The streams mix without reaction or loss. What is the outlet salt mass fraction?
The student’s attempt
10 × 0.20 + 10 × 0 = 2, so the outlet is 2% salt.
One guiding question
What flow rate should you divide 2 kg/h by to get the outlet salt mass fraction?
Write down your next line before opening the check.
Reveal the calculation
The salt flow is 2 kg/h. The total outlet flow is 10 + 10 = 20 kg/h. Divide the salt flow by the total outlet flow.
(2 kg/h) ÷ (20 kg/h) = 0.10 = 10% salt by mass.
The flow units cancel. That gives you a mass fraction, which you can express as a percentage.
Copy the AI tutor prompt
Act as my engineering tutor. Read the problem and my working below. Identify the first line that needs attention and ask me one guiding question about it. If you need more information, ask one clarifying question. Wait for my attempt before showing the next calculation or the final answer.
Problem: [Paste the full question, including units and assumptions.]
My working: [Paste each step, including units. Mark the line where you got stuck.]
Try a second problem
Mix 15 kg/h of a 20% salt solution by mass with 5 kg/h of pure water. Assume no reaction or loss. What is the outlet salt mass fraction?
- Think. Write your attempt and mark any line you are unsure about.
- Ask. If you get stuck, use the prompt to request one guiding question.
- Judge. Check whether the question fits your working. Verify the units and assumptions against your course notes.
- Accomplish. Finish the calculation and explain in one sentence what each flow rate in your final division represents.
Check your practice answer
The salt flow is 15 × 0.20 = 3 kg/h. The total outlet flow is 15 + 5 = 20 kg/h. The outlet salt mass fraction is 3 ÷ 20 = 0.15, or 15% salt by mass.
Try it on your own work. Pick an unfinished problem from your notes. Ask for one hint, then see whether you can write the next line yourself.


