AIYING ANALYSIS · PRACTICE CARD 005
The Assignment AI Could Finish
Ravindra Dastikop with ChatGPT
We were taught to assess the finished assignment. Now that AI can help produce it, what should we learn to do?
A student submits a persuasive essay with a clear claim and well-placed evidence. You can assess the essay as a piece of writing. To see whether the student can choose evidence for a claim, give them a small decision to make in front of you.
Unlearn this. Treating polished work as sufficient evidence of understanding. Start learning this. Ask for a short demonstration tied to the learning goal. Decide in advance what you will look for in the response.
Why this card asks for a demonstration
Australia’s Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency frames assessment reform around both learning to work with AI and gathering trustworthy evidence of learning. Its guidance is for higher education. Card 005 adapts that principle into a short follow-up that school and college teachers can try. TEQSA, Assessment Reform for the Age of Artificial Intelligence, 2023.
In a high-school mathematics field experiment, students using unrestricted AI improved during practice but performed worse on an unaided assessment than students who practised without AI. A tutoring version designed to provide hints largely mitigated that downside. The study tested maths tutoring. Card 005 uses an independent attempt as a design choice, and a workshop pilot could test whether teachers find the exercise useful. Bastani et al., PNAS, 2025.
Try it in ten minutes
- The goal of a persuasive essay is to use evidence to support a claim. Design a two-minute follow-up and write down one observable sign of understanding.
- Ask AI whether a student could pass by repeating a memorised line. Have it ask you one question, then revise your follow-up.
- Try a fresh case without AI. A student submits a chart, and the goal is to choose a chart that fits the data and question. Design a short demonstration and one success criterion.
In a faculty workshop, give pairs the same learning goal and compare what each follow-up would reveal. Let students respond orally, in writing, or by annotating their work when those formats assess the same skill. Use the follow-up as one piece of evidence about learning.
How will I know I am learning this?
I can design a follow-up that makes the target skill visible.

