Ravindra Dastikop with ChatGPT
We were taught to study worked examples until each step made sense. Now that AI can help with that, what should we learn to do?
An AI tutor explains a percentage problem. Every step makes sense as you read it. Then the numbers and the situation change, and you have to decide where to start. That is the moment Practice Card 003 asks you to rehearse.
Unlearn this. Moving on as soon as an explanation feels clear. Start learning this. Apply the same idea to a fresh problem and explain why your method works.
Why the card asks for an independent attempt
In a high-school mathematics field experiment, students using unrestricted AI improved during practice but performed worse on an unaided assessment than students who had practised without AI. A tutor designed to give hints largely mitigated that downside. This gives us a reason to test unaided performance in Card 003. The study tested tutoring, and the card’s effectiveness still needs a pilot. Bastani et al., PNAS, 2025.
In separate experiments, Andrew Butler found that repeated testing improved later retention and application to new questions compared with repeated study. This helps explain why the card changes the problem after feedback. A single fresh problem gives you an immediate check on whether you can reuse the idea. Butler, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 2010.
Try it in ten minutes
- A price drops from ₹100 to ₹80. What percentage increase restores the original price? Write an answer and name the amount you used as the base.
- Share the problem and your attempt with AI. Ask it to check your reasoning and ask one question about the base you chose. Revise before asking for the solution.
- Without AI or hints, try a new case. A club’s membership fell from 60 to 45. By what percentage must it grow to return to 60? Apply your percentage to 45 to check whether it restores the original membership.
Teachers can use this as a short classroom exercise for students who already know basic percentages. Have learners compare their choice of base after everyone has attempted the club problem. The card also works for independent study and belongs in the Check Before You Trust AI workshop pack.
How will I know I am learning this?
I can solve a fresh problem without hints and explain which amount I used as the base and why.



