AIYINGFrom AI Awareness to Accomplishment
Showing posts with label Patterns of the Past. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Patterns of the Past. Show all posts

Monday, November 16, 2026

Edward de Bono’s Concept Fan: Are Your Ten AI Ideas Really One? | Patterns of the Past #003

PATTERNS OF THE PAST · V12.0 · #003

Edward de Bono’s Concept Fan: Are Your Ten AI Ideas Really One?


Old Knowledge. New Possibilities.

AIYING · By Ravindra Dastikop

You ask AI for ten ideas.

The wording changes. The examples change. Yet several suggestions may still rely on the same approach.

For this edition, we revisit Edward de Bono’s concept fan: a structure for exploring alternatives at different levels.

The past practice: organise the search for alternatives

De Bono’s concept fan belongs to his toolkit for deliberate creative thinking. His own Serious Creativity article refers to using it to organise concepts; the De Bono Group also identifies concept extraction and the concept fan among its lateral-thinking tools. These sources establish attribution and use, rather than proving effectiveness in every setting. [1] [2]

For this activity, we will use a simplified working structure:

Four levels of the working structure
LevelQuestion
PurposeWhat are we trying to accomplish?
DirectionWhat broad route could help achieve it?
ConceptWhat general mechanism could serve that direction?
IdeaWhat specific action could put that mechanism into practice?

The useful movement goes both ways: from a particular idea back to the approach behind it, then outward to other ways of achieving the purpose.

PO is not required for this exercise. The concept fan supplies the structure.

The pattern beneath the tool

When several ideas lead down the same route, step back to the purpose and explore other routes.

This is our practical interpretation for the adaptation.

GenAI’s proposed contribution is to help classify suggestions, expose repeated mechanisms, and develop branches we have not explored.

It can also create the appearance of variety by giving similar ideas different labels. We therefore need to inspect the relationships, not count the suggestions.

What must hold: The purpose must reflect the actual need, and each branch must have a plausible connection to it.

Where the pattern breaks: Categories can overlap, important routes can be omitted, and an orderly map can contain impractical ideas. The map does not establish effectiveness.

Begin with a purpose that leaves room to think

Consider this fictional request:

“How can we get more people to attend our Sunday morning clean-up?”

Attendance may matter. But suppose the organiser’s real concern is accumulated litter.

A broader purpose might be:

“Reduce litter in our neighbourhood with a manageable burden on volunteers.”

That opens possibilities beyond one event.

However, broadening the purpose is a decision. If bringing neighbours together is itself essential, removing the gathering could lose something important.

Confirm what must be preserved before expanding the search.

Build a small fan

Here is an illustrative map—not a report of solutions already tested.

Purpose: Reduce neighbourhood litter without overloading volunteers.

Illustrative concept fan
DirectionConceptConcrete idea
Prevent some litterMake disposal easier at a recurring litter pointAsk the responsible authority about a suitable bin location and collection arrangements
Increase participationLower the time commitmentOffer a fifteen-minute clean-up option
Distribute the workGive small areas clear ownershipInvite willing groups to adopt a short stretch
Improve collectionCoordinate with existing servicesAgree how collected bags will be removed before organising the event

These proposals require local checks. A bin without collection arrangements, for example, could create another problem.

The table’s value is that the ideas act through different mechanisms. The directions are not claimed to be exhaustive or mutually exclusive.

Use GenAI to examine your first list

Write down three ideas of your own before consulting AI.

Then use this prompt:

Help me build a simplified concept fan inspired by Edward de Bono’s method.

Situation: [Describe.]
Purpose: [State the desired outcome.]
What must be preserved: [Include important social or practical values.]
Constraints: [Time, money, access, permissions.]
My first three ideas: [Insert.]

First, identify the general mechanism behind each idea. Flag ideas that use substantially the same mechanism.

Suggest up to three broader directions. Explain how each could contribute to the purpose. Ask me to confirm them before expanding.

After confirmation, propose two concepts under each direction and one concrete idea under each concept.

Show the chain: purpose → direction → concept → idea.

Identify overlaps, assumptions, missing information, and proposals outside our control.

Do not claim the map is exhaustive or that a plausible idea will work. Keep generation separate from evaluation.

The branch counts are instructions for this exercise, not a rule attributed to de Bono.

Check whether the fan contains real alternatives

For each proposed branch, ask:

  • Connection: How could this contribute to the purpose?
  • Difference: Does it work through a different mechanism, or repeat another branch?
  • Specificity: Is the idea concrete enough to try?
  • Conditions: What information, permissions, resources, or cooperation would it need?

Compare the map with your original three ideas. Record one useful distinction it added—or record that it did not add anything useful.

Choose an action using criteria suited to the situation, such as likely contribution, cost, accessibility, volunteer effort, and feasibility.

Test one branch

For the fictional clean-up, suppose the group selects the fifteen-minute option.

Before organising it, ask potential participants:

“Would a fifteen-minute option change whether you could participate? What would still make it difficult?”

Their answers may support the proposal—or reveal that equipment, accessibility, timing, or bag removal matters more.

If the group proceeds, record:

Before the testAfter the test
Expected participationActual participation
Planned volunteer effortActual effort
Intended litter removalWhat was removed and how collection worked
Assumptions about accessDifficulties participants reported

A small test can inform the next decision. It cannot establish a general rule about community participation.

If the activity has not happened, label the result “Not yet tested.”

Your accomplishment

Finish with:

  • A purpose you can explain.
  • A map containing genuinely different approaches.
  • One selected action with a reason for choosing it.
  • A test record—or a clearly labelled plan if it has not happened yet.

You can build the fan entirely on paper. Judge AI assistance by whether it helps reveal useful alternatives, not by how many branches it produces.

Open the next possibility

A test may reveal a constraint that belongs in the next version of your map.

For example, if people have time but cannot reach the meeting point, reducing the time commitment may not address the real obstacle. Revisit the purpose and explore another route.

Sources and evidence note

  1. Edward de Bono: Serious Creativity.
  2. De Bono Group: Leading/Facilitating High Performance Design Thinking.

Sources checked on 16 November 2026. The four-level structure is presented as a simplified teaching explanation. The neighbourhood example, prompt, and testing procedure are proposed applications, not evidence of a completed experiment.

Patterns of the Past · V12.0 · #003 · AIYING · Ravindra Dastikop
The past supplies patterns. GenAI helps explore connections. Present experience decides what works.

PATTERNS OF THE PAST · V12.0 · #002

Peter Drucker’s Feedback Analysis: Can AI Help You Learn from Your Own Decisions?



Old Knowledge. New Possibilities.

AIYING · By Ravindra Dastikop

A decision worth learning from

You introduce a new activity, change a work process, or accept a responsibility.

Later, you decide whether it went well.

But what exactly did you expect before you began?

For this edition, we revisit Peter Drucker’s feedback analysis: preserving expectations so that experience has something specific to challenge.

The past practice: record expectations, then compare

Drucker described feedback analysis as a way to investigate personal strengths. Record important decisions or actions alongside their expected results, then compare expectations with outcomes nine to twelve months later. The September 12 entry in The Daily Drucker presents this as a repeated practice extending over years. [1]

The historical method therefore involves more than reflecting after an event. It preserves an expectation that can later be examined.

This edition adapts that structure. It does not claim that Drucker proposed an AI system or that the adaptation below has been validated.

The pattern beneath the practice

Preserve an expectation before acting. Compare it with evidence afterwards. Use the difference to question how you work.
The pattern card
Pattern element What we preserve Proposed GenAI adaptation
Expectation A dated account of what you think will happen Ask AI to identify vague wording and unstated assumptions
Action What you decided to do Keep the original decision separate from later changes
Result Evidence of what happened Organise observations without filling missing information
Comparison Expected versus actual outcomes Generate possible explanations and counter-explanations
Learning A decision about future practice Examine recurring differences across several records

What must hold: Expectations and results need enough detail to compare.

Where the pattern breaks: Results reflect circumstances, other people’s contributions, chance, and measurement choices. A successful outcome does not establish a personal strength; a disappointing result does not establish incapacity.

A present difficulty: repeating activity without accumulating learning

Consider a fictional teacher who introduces a new classroom activity.

Afterwards, the teacher remembers that students seemed enthusiastic. The activity enters next term’s lesson plan.

But the original purpose was to help students explain a concept independently.

Enthusiasm and independent explanation are different outcomes.

A decision record could preserve that distinction before the activity begins.

Make your first expectation card

Choose one modest decision with an observable result. Complete this before acting:

FieldWhat to write
Decision ID and dateD01; date recorded
SituationWhat needs attention?
ActionWhat will I do?
Expected resultWhat specifically do I expect to happen?
ReasonWhy do I expect that result?
AssumptionsWhat am I taking for granted?
EvidenceWhat will I observe or collect?
Review pointWhen should a meaningful result be visible?

Keep the original entry unchanged. Append revisions with dates.

For a short activity, you can rehearse this comparison within days or weeks. That shorter review is our adaptation, not Drucker’s nine-to-twelve-month interval, and it cannot substitute for examining longer-term development.

A worked fictional example

Suppose the teacher records:

Now imagine the following illustrative result:

Sixteen students completed the paired exercise. Nine met both criteria in the individual exit task.

These numbers are invented to demonstrate the comparison.

They create a useful discrepancy: successful participation exceeded demonstrated independent performance.

They do not establish why.

Possible explanations include insufficient practice, partners completing different shares of the work, or a changed example that introduced an additional difficulty. Those explanations need investigation.

Where GenAI could contribute

With several records, an assistant could help look for candidate patterns:

  • Expectations repeatedly exceed independent performance.
  • A particular approach works only under certain conditions.
  • Several apparent failures share an external constraint.
  • The evidence collected does not match the intended outcome.

These are possibilities to examine—not conclusions about your personality or competence.

GenAI can also produce a coherent explanation that the records do not support. Require it to show which entries support each interpretation.

Use this review prompt

Help me review these decision records using the expectation–result comparison associated with Drucker’s feedback analysis.

This is an AI-assisted adaptation, not a claim that Drucker designed this workflow.

For each record:
  1. Preserve the original expectation exactly.
  2. Separate observed results from interpretations.
  3. Identify the difference between expectation and result.
  4. State whether the evidence actually measures the intended outcome.
  5. Suggest possible explanations, including contextual factors and explanations that challenge my preferred account.
  6. Identify missing evidence. Do not fill gaps.
Across the records, propose candidate recurring patterns. Cite record IDs and identify counterexamples.

Do not infer a stable strength or weakness from one event, or present correlation as causation.

End with one question to investigate and one small change I could test.

Records: [Paste dated entries.]

Check the response against your records yourself. Use anonymised or fictional records for practice; exclude identifiable student, client, or colleague information.

Test whether AI adds value

Before using the prompt, write your own short comparison.

Then examine the AI-assisted review:

  • Did it reveal a discrepancy you had overlooked?
  • Did it identify a genuine counterexample?
  • Did it distinguish evidence from an attractive explanation?
  • Did it introduce an unsupported claim?

Keep a useful insight only if you can trace it to the records.

If you have no dated expectations, begin a prospective record today. Retrospective recollections may provide context, but label them as recollections.

You can complete the entire exercise on paper. The comparison with your own review helps you assess whether AI contributed anything useful in this instance.

Your accomplishment

Start with one complete decision record.

When the review point arrives, append the evidence, your comparison, and the next question. Until then, mark the outcome “Not yet observed.”

Over time, you can build a collection that helps you investigate how your expectations meet experience.

The first accomplishment is modest and concrete:

A decision you can learn from without rewriting what you originally expected.

Source and evidence note

[1] Peter F. Drucker, The Daily Drucker — September 12: Managing Oneself: Identify Strengths.

Source checked on 16 November 2026. The classroom example, additional record fields, shorter rehearsal interval, and GenAI workflow are proposed adaptations. They are not reported research results or claims that Drucker specified this AI-assisted process.

Patterns of the Past · V12.0 · #002 · AIYING · Ravindra Dastikop
The past supplies patterns. GenAI helps explore connections. Present experience decides what works.

The Commonplace Book: Turn Saved Notes into New Possibilities | Patterns of the Past #001

PATTERNS OF THE PAST · V12.0 · #001

The Commonplace Book: Can Your Saved Notes Help You Start Something?



Old Knowledge. New Possibilities.

AIYING · By Ravindra Dastikop

You saved the article because it mattered.

You highlighted a passage, copied a quotation, and bookmarked another useful explanation.

Weeks later, you face a problem. Somewhere in those notes is something that might help.

But where—and how?

For our first edition, we revisit the commonplace book: a historical practice of collecting and organising material for later reference. We will explore an adaptation in which GenAI helps examine connections between a small collection of notes and a present difficulty.

A practice from the past

A commonplace book was a place to gather selected material from reading, often organised under headings or through an index.

Harvard Library’s exhibition documents George Ripley’s nineteenth-century notebook, which combined excerpts, poems, observations, and reading notes. Entries included source references. The exhibition also describes John Locke’s indexing method for locating material entered across different notebook pages. [1]

Another notebook in the exhibition illustrates a practical difficulty: assigning pages to subjects in advance could leave some sections empty while others overflowed. Locke’s method addressed that allocation problem. He developed a method within an existing practice; he did not invent the commonplace book. [2]

The past offers both a useful practice and a warning: an organising system can become cumbersome. Ripley himself did not consistently follow the indexing scheme associated with his notebook. [1]

The pattern beneath the notebook

The useful connection is not simply that people once saved quotations on paper.

It is this:

Select something worth retaining, preserve its context, and make it available for another occasion.

That is our interpretation of the practice—not a claim that every historical notebook served the same purpose.

The pattern card
Pattern elementWhat we preserveWhat we adapt
SelectionSomeone decides what deserves attentionBegin with a small, deliberately chosen collection
ContextMaterial remains connected to its sourceKeep source details beside each note
OrganisationEntries can be found and revisitedAsk AI to propose several possible groupings
ReuseEarlier material can inform later workExamine connections to one present difficulty

What must hold: The notes must contain enough context to interpret responsibly.

Where the pattern breaks: A collection can contain mistakes, outdated advice, and incompatible assumptions. Saving something does not establish its truth.

The new possibility

A conventional search might help you find a note containing a particular word.

In this experiment, ask GenAI to examine several notes together:

  • Which describe a similar relationship?
  • Which disagree?
  • Which might inform this situation?
  • Which connections are merely superficial?

GenAI’s proposed role is to generate candidate connections and explain them. You check whether those explanations fit the notes and the situation.

A convincing connection is still a hypothesis.

Begin with one present difficulty

Use a real, modest problem.

For example, consider this fictional situation:

A community reading group has lively discussions, but members rarely try anything suggested between meetings.

Before consulting AI, write your own first explanation and one possible response.

This creates a starting point for comparison.

Then select five notes that might be relevant. They need not share a keyword.

Use your own observations or short excerpts you can appropriately reuse. Keep quotations separate from paraphrases.

Build five note cards

Give each note an identifier:

FieldWhat to record
IDN1, N2, N3, N4, or N5
ContentShort excerpt, paraphrase, or observation
SourceAuthor, title, page or URL; or the circumstances of your observation
ContextWhat situation the material originally concerned
Your commentWhy you retained it
UncertaintyWhat needs checking

Keep the collection small enough to review yourself. A notebook or ordinary document is sufficient.

Ask AI to explore the connections

Use this prompt:

I am adapting the commonplace-book practice to explore a present difficulty.

My difficulty: [Describe it.]
My first explanation and possible response: [Insert.]
My five notes: [Paste N1–N5 with their source details.]

Work only from these notes when describing their contents.
  1. Identify up to three candidate relationships across the notes. Cite the note IDs supporting each.
  2. Distinguish shared mechanisms from similarities in wording.
  3. Identify disagreements, missing context, and connections that may be weak.
  4. Propose three different responses to my difficulty. Explain which notes inform each and where the adaptation introduces a new assumption.
  5. Include the possibility that these notes do not adequately support a useful response.
  6. Help me choose one small experiment using criteria we state explicitly.
Do not invent quotations, sources, historical claims, or evidence of effectiveness. Label your proposals as proposals.

Turn one connection into an idea card

Review the AI’s suggestions against the original notes.

Reject any connection you cannot explain in your own words.

Then complete:

For the fictional reading group, one possible adaptation might be:

End a meeting with each willing member choosing a five-minute action and deciding what observation to bring back.

This is an illustrative proposal. It is not a result established by the historical practice or by notes we have actually analysed here.

Test usefulness, not elegance

First compare the selected idea with your original response.

Did examining the notes add a relevant distinction, reveal a weakness, or produce a different action? Record what changed.

Then, where feasible, try the action.

CheckEvidence to record
Source fidelityDo the cited notes actually support the interpretation?
ContributionWhat changed from your initial idea?
PracticalityCan the proposed action be carried out within the constraints?
OutcomeWhat happened when you tried it?
LimitationWhat remains uncertain or unexplained?

For the reading-group example, you might record how many members voluntarily chose an action, attempted it, and returned with an observation. Do not assume participation means learning—or that one successful meeting establishes lasting improvement.

If you have not run the test, write “Not yet tested.”

You can also perform the same exercise on paper by arranging the five cards and looking for connections yourself. Comparing that process with AI assistance may help you judge whether the assistant added value in this task.

Your accomplishment

The intended result is:

One source-linked idea card, one small experiment, and a record of what happened.

You may discover that the notes were useful. You may discover that your first idea was better. You may discover that you need different evidence.

Each result can guide the next inquiry.

Let the collection grow through use

Add one final note:

“I tried this because… What happened was… The next question is…”

Your collection now contains an observation about applying what you saved.

That observation can become material for a later decision.

Sources and evidence note

  1. Harvard Library, Take Note: Precepts put into practice — George Ripley’s notebook and the discussion of Locke’s method.
  2. Harvard Library, Take Note: The cost of a Harvard education — Samuel Locke’s notebook and the problem of allocating pages to headings.

Historical references checked on 16 November 2026. The pattern card is an editorial interpretation. The AI workflow, reading-group example, and experiment are proposed adaptations, not research-validated outcomes or reports of a completed test.

Patterns of the Past · V12.0 · #001 · AIYING · Ravindra Dastikop
The past supplies patterns. GenAI helps explore connections. Present experience decides what works.

Accomplish with AI

Powered by Blogger.

Featured post

Digital Skills for Beginners: Build Confidence with AI-Assisted Practice

AIYING · V14.0 · FIRST DIGITAL STEPS “I Can Do It When You Show Me.” What Happens When You’re Not There? ...

Search This Blog

List of blogs

Search This Blog

About

Translate

Instant Stories

Read in Your Language

Test

share this

ShareThis

Popular Posts