PATTERNS OF THE PAST · V12.0 · #003
Edward de Bono’s Concept Fan: Are Your Ten AI Ideas Really One?
AIYING · By Ravindra Dastikop
You ask AI for ten ideas.
The wording changes. The examples change. Yet several suggestions may still rely on the same approach.
For this edition, we revisit Edward de Bono’s concept fan: a structure for exploring alternatives at different levels.
The past practice: organise the search for alternatives
De Bono’s concept fan belongs to his toolkit for deliberate creative thinking. His own Serious Creativity article refers to using it to organise concepts; the De Bono Group also identifies concept extraction and the concept fan among its lateral-thinking tools. These sources establish attribution and use, rather than proving effectiveness in every setting. [1] [2]
For this activity, we will use a simplified working structure:
| Level | Question |
|---|---|
| Purpose | What are we trying to accomplish? |
| Direction | What broad route could help achieve it? |
| Concept | What general mechanism could serve that direction? |
| Idea | What specific action could put that mechanism into practice? |
The useful movement goes both ways: from a particular idea back to the approach behind it, then outward to other ways of achieving the purpose.
PO is not required for this exercise. The concept fan supplies the structure.
The pattern beneath the tool
When several ideas lead down the same route, step back to the purpose and explore other routes.
This is our practical interpretation for the adaptation.
GenAI’s proposed contribution is to help classify suggestions, expose repeated mechanisms, and develop branches we have not explored.
It can also create the appearance of variety by giving similar ideas different labels. We therefore need to inspect the relationships, not count the suggestions.
What must hold: The purpose must reflect the actual need, and each branch must have a plausible connection to it.
Where the pattern breaks: Categories can overlap, important routes can be omitted, and an orderly map can contain impractical ideas. The map does not establish effectiveness.
Begin with a purpose that leaves room to think
Consider this fictional request:
“How can we get more people to attend our Sunday morning clean-up?”
Attendance may matter. But suppose the organiser’s real concern is accumulated litter.
A broader purpose might be:
“Reduce litter in our neighbourhood with a manageable burden on volunteers.”
That opens possibilities beyond one event.
However, broadening the purpose is a decision. If bringing neighbours together is itself essential, removing the gathering could lose something important.
Confirm what must be preserved before expanding the search.
Build a small fan
Here is an illustrative map—not a report of solutions already tested.
Purpose: Reduce neighbourhood litter without overloading volunteers.
| Direction | Concept | Concrete idea |
|---|---|---|
| Prevent some litter | Make disposal easier at a recurring litter point | Ask the responsible authority about a suitable bin location and collection arrangements |
| Increase participation | Lower the time commitment | Offer a fifteen-minute clean-up option |
| Distribute the work | Give small areas clear ownership | Invite willing groups to adopt a short stretch |
| Improve collection | Coordinate with existing services | Agree how collected bags will be removed before organising the event |
These proposals require local checks. A bin without collection arrangements, for example, could create another problem.
The table’s value is that the ideas act through different mechanisms. The directions are not claimed to be exhaustive or mutually exclusive.
Use GenAI to examine your first list
Write down three ideas of your own before consulting AI.
Then use this prompt:
Help me build a simplified concept fan inspired by Edward de Bono’s method.
Situation: [Describe.]
Purpose: [State the desired outcome.]
What must be preserved: [Include important social or practical values.]
Constraints: [Time, money, access, permissions.]
My first three ideas: [Insert.]
First, identify the general mechanism behind each idea. Flag ideas that use substantially the same mechanism.
Suggest up to three broader directions. Explain how each could contribute to the purpose. Ask me to confirm them before expanding.
After confirmation, propose two concepts under each direction and one concrete idea under each concept.
Show the chain: purpose → direction → concept → idea.
Identify overlaps, assumptions, missing information, and proposals outside our control.
Do not claim the map is exhaustive or that a plausible idea will work. Keep generation separate from evaluation.
The branch counts are instructions for this exercise, not a rule attributed to de Bono.
Check whether the fan contains real alternatives
For each proposed branch, ask:
- Connection: How could this contribute to the purpose?
- Difference: Does it work through a different mechanism, or repeat another branch?
- Specificity: Is the idea concrete enough to try?
- Conditions: What information, permissions, resources, or cooperation would it need?
Compare the map with your original three ideas. Record one useful distinction it added—or record that it did not add anything useful.
Choose an action using criteria suited to the situation, such as likely contribution, cost, accessibility, volunteer effort, and feasibility.
Test one branch
For the fictional clean-up, suppose the group selects the fifteen-minute option.
Before organising it, ask potential participants:
“Would a fifteen-minute option change whether you could participate? What would still make it difficult?”
Their answers may support the proposal—or reveal that equipment, accessibility, timing, or bag removal matters more.
If the group proceeds, record:
| Before the test | After the test |
|---|---|
| Expected participation | Actual participation |
| Planned volunteer effort | Actual effort |
| Intended litter removal | What was removed and how collection worked |
| Assumptions about access | Difficulties participants reported |
A small test can inform the next decision. It cannot establish a general rule about community participation.
If the activity has not happened, label the result “Not yet tested.”
Your accomplishment
Finish with:
- A purpose you can explain.
- A map containing genuinely different approaches.
- One selected action with a reason for choosing it.
- A test record—or a clearly labelled plan if it has not happened yet.
You can build the fan entirely on paper. Judge AI assistance by whether it helps reveal useful alternatives, not by how many branches it produces.
Open the next possibility
A test may reveal a constraint that belongs in the next version of your map.
For example, if people have time but cannot reach the meeting point, reducing the time commitment may not address the real obstacle. Revisit the purpose and explore another route.
Sources and evidence note
- Edward de Bono: Serious Creativity.
- De Bono Group: Leading/Facilitating High Performance Design Thinking.
Sources checked on 16 November 2026. The four-level structure is presented as a simplified teaching explanation. The neighbourhood example, prompt, and testing procedure are proposed applications, not evidence of a completed experiment.


No comments:
Post a Comment